Coal Powered Economy Causing Suffering of India & Beyond -Anthony Ciaramitaro

“We find dirt and dust on everything,” states Ramji Basor, a struggling farmer living in the shadow of one of India’s many coal power plants (Bengail). Much of the Indian population is getting used to this daily occurrence. Winds blow coal dust over numerous crops and drinking wells, and heavy rains rush mass amounts of soil into villages that consist of dirty, cracked homes from mine blasting. The country is engulfed in a thick air that not only coats its surroundings, but also making it very hard to breath. The desire to industrialize an economy around coal power has left the people and environment of India suffering, in addition to contribution of global climate change.

iWzhoLO3G6XQOf India’s 1.25 billion people, only 300 million have electricity, making demand for energy extremely high. While trying to bring electricity to the rest of the population, India has ignored the international push to reduce carbon emissions. Currently, India consumes 800 million tons of coal yearly to produce a whopping 70% of its energy. Only 17% of India’s power comes from hydropower, while 10% comes from renewable sources such as wind, and 2% from nuclear power (Martain). India relies heavily on their domestic coal resources because it is the cheapest way to create energy and continue their recent economic growth (Cropper). Regardless of this fact, using the domestic resource has weighed a rather heavy cost, as the burning of coal to produce energy has left its mark on not only the environment, but also human health.

Anywhere that coal is burned the surrounding la-la-fg-india-us-coal01-jpg-20151014environment suffers. Like many forms of energy, coal burned energy is created through the boiling of water that creates steam, which rises to spins large turbines. Coal combustion releases emissions of CO2, sulfur dioxide, nitrogen oxides, particulate matter, carbon monoxide, volatile organic compounds, and various trace metals like mercury over large areas of land (Guttikunda). As theses pollutants enter the atmosphere, smog, acid rain, and toxic air pollution begins to create a chain of environmental destruction. Effects such as smog and acid rain contaminate the water cycles allowing rivers, lakes, drinking water sources, and soil to become contaminated (Guttikunda). As the environment around the plant becomes effected, enormous amounts of health effects are placed on residents within the area. Lung cancer, respiratory illnesses, and heart diseases all have been ruled into relation with coal burned energy. And in 2010, Global Disease Studies noted India’s air pollution among the top ten health risks of the country, with an estimated 695,000 premature deaths from respiratory illnesses (Guttikunda).

While the rest of the world tries to reduce the CO2 emissions they emit, India does little to regulate the amounts they release. Ranking first in world percent increase of carbon emission in the past year, India’s emissions jumped 5.1%; the biggest jump ever recorded by a country. Compared to the United States who only rose 2.9 %, and the European Union, which fell by 1.8 %. India’s total emission is ranked fourth according to World Bank, while China, US, and Russia all currently lead. But, if India’s economy continues to produce the amount of greenhouse gasses like the past year, they could soon move up in rankings and further putting the world at risk of climate change destruction (Oskin).

*note this does not include recent to 2015

*Note this does not include recent to 2015 (Not available on World Bank)

Traditionally, the use and effect of coal has been seen mostly in the United States. The electrification of America began 1882 when Thomas Edison developed the first coal-fired power plant (Steinberg). By the end of the century the United States produced more coal than any other nation and had an economy that functioned under the use of primarily coal powered railroads (Steinberg). As rail- roads began to expand across the United States the demand for coal, similar to India’s for energy, became evident. More recently we have seen more demand for the coal industry when president George W. Bush was elected in 2000. According to Steinberg, under President Bush about half of the United States energy came from coal plants, and was responsible for 39% of the nation’s carbon emission. Furthermore in 2007, President Bush, powering his energy policy around coal, called for 150 new coal-fired power plants to be built in the US (Steinberg). Under Bush the nation was unaware of the implications of using coal until the realization in Martin County, West Virginia when Massey Coal Energy Company found that its wastewater pond had been contaminated with volumes of black sludge that contaminated the drinking water of 27,000 people (Steinberg).

Though economically coal seems to be the best option because it is the cheapest form of energy and is abundant, it does have many negative externalities. When looking back in the United States history it is clear that coal powered economies are unsafe and pose major threats to the environment. India in the future should look to cleaner forms of energy to power their economy like solar or wind. If India does not change the way they are operating they will harm their residents, their beautiful country, and catalyze global climate change.

For more information, see:

Ted Steinberg, Down to Earth:  Nature’s Role in American History, 3rd edition (New York:  Oxford University Press, 2013):  chapter 16.

Atmospheric Emissions and Pollution From The coal-fired thermal power plants in India: http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S135223101400329X?np=y

The Hidden Costs: Health Effects of Coal Electricity Generation in India :

http://www.rff.org/files/sharepoint/WorkImages/Download/RFF-Resources-180_Feature-CropperMalik.pdf

Coal-fueled Economy taking a toll on environment

http://www.latimes.com/world/asia/la-fg-india-us-coal-20151015-story.html

Climate Change Takes A Backseat to Coal powered Development:

http://www.eenews.net/stories/1060026415

http://www.livescience.com/47929-global-carbon-emissions-2014-record.html

World Bank

http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/EN.ATM.CO2E.KT/countries/IN-US-EU?display=graph

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Coal Powered Economy Causing Suffering of India & Beyond -Anthony Ciaramitaro

  1. awshue

    This is a really well written post Anthony, I enjoyed the facts, figures and in-depth information you provided on the coal process. Some of the issues remind me of what farmers experienced during the Dust Bowl in the US. Its obviously horrible for the health of India which is concerning. I wonder if India’s close relationship with the US will eventually result in them lowering their coal emissions?

    Reply
  2. Clairee Putnam

    Anthony, this was a great blog! I was fascinated to learn about the extreme use of power in India. It was shocking to me that of India’s 1.25 billion people, only 300 million have electricity, and they still produce 800 million tons of coal. Additionally, the information about the pollutants in the atmosphere causing smog, acid rain, and toxic air pollution, reminded me of the video we just watched in class regarding the toxic air and pollution of lakes and rivers in Mexico City. Clearly this is a global issue. Great blog!

    Reply
  3. katieneyland

    This article was written very well! I though it was extremely thorough and covered all aspects of the subject. I liked how you talked about the local and global aspect. It’s very interesting to think about how important it is control coal emissions but at the same time how that might take electricity from the poor in India. The reason that countries like America have to privilege of alternative energy is that we have had to privilege of developing as a country while using dirty energy sources before climate change became a known issue. This posses the question if it is fair for countries like us to impose strict energy laws on countries still developing while we never had to follows rules like this ourselves.

    Reply
  4. Sarah McVann Post author

    This was very interesting to read, i was not aware that a country like india was still so reliant on coal for energy. When i fist began reading, this reminded me of the coal use in London, and how the birch trees turned black, and so did the moths. The effects that the pollution from coal is having on the people in india is scary. Hopefully they can find another cheap alternative in order to clean up their living environment.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s